Ranking Every Race Shoe from Most to Least Aggressive
Below we will help you pick out a race shoe for your upcoming 5k, 10k, half marathon or marathon based on how aggressive or comfortable you like your race shoe to be. We’ll cover the most aggressive shoes like the Puma Fast-R 3, Nike Streakfly 2, and ASICS Metaspeed Sky Tokyo, to more balanced options like the Adidas Adios Pro 4 and Hoka Cielo X1 2.0, to more comfort-oriented and approachable shoes like the New Balance SC Elite v5 and the On Cloudboom Max.
There are three types of Carbon County race shoes out there: Aggressive, Balanced and Approachable. Here's where every popular race shoe fits in. If you're looking for the ultimate speed weapon, you'll want a shoe in the aggressive bracket from 1 to 8. If you're looking for a blend of speed and comfort, check out one of the balanced racers in 8 to 15. For the most comfortable carbon shoes, the approachable racers from 16 to 23 are your best bet.
Aggressive: #1-8
These shoes actively put you on your toes in an attacking stance, rewarding the greater power outputs generated by fast paces. The Nike Streakfly 2 and Puma Fast-R 3 are the fastest, most stripped-back demon time shoes on the market, necessitating strong running form. The Streakfly 2 is great for shorter race distances, from the mile up to the 5K and the Fast-R 3 would be great for the 10K up to the marathon distance. If you’re looking for a fast racer but still want a cushioned, elevated ride with the sensation of plenty of foam underfoot, we recommend the ASICS Metaspeed Ray, Adidas Adios Pro Evo 2 and Mizuno Wave Rebellion Pro 3. We also highly recommend the ASICS Metaspeed Sky Tokyo and Nike Alphafly 3 for their ability to strike a solid balance between explosive speed and cushion.
Nike Streakfly 2
.png)
Puma Fast-R Nitro Elite 3
ASICS Metaspeed Ray
ASICS Metaspeed Sky Tokyo
Balanced: #8-15
Shoes in this category blend responsiveness with comfort, working well across a wide variety of pace ranges and footstrikes. Some offer aggressive geometries mixed with squishy, comfortable foams (Adidas Adios Pro 4, Saucony Endorphin Elite 2, Hoka Cielo X1 2.0) while others feature more traditional rocker profiles with not too soft, not too firm midsoles (ASICS Metaspeed Edge Tokyo, Nike Vaporfly 4, Brooks Hyperion Elite 5, Puma Deviate Nitro Elite 3 & Mizuno Wave Rebellion Pro 3 Lo). This tier is the sweet spot for the 3:00-4:00 hour marathon range.
Adidas Adios Pro 4
Hoka Cielo X1 2.0
%20(2).png)
Brooks Hyperion Elite 5
Mizuno Wave Rebellion Pro 3 Lo
Approachable / Comfort-Oriented: #16-23
If you plan on spending more than 4 hours on your feet during a marathon, you might consider one of these comfort-oriented race shoes. Whether you’re looking for something plush yet relatively fast & lightweight (On Cloudboom Stike, New Balance SC Elite v5), normal-feeling, reliable & stable (Saucony Endorphin Pro 4, Hoka Rocket X3), or fun, bouncy, and soft (Tracksmith Eliot Racer & Diadora Gara Carbon 2), these shoes prioritize long distance comfort without skimping on performance. The Adidas Takumi Sen 11 and On Cloudboom Max are here for the wrong reasons—they ride more like daily trainers, lacking the pop of true racing shoes.
New Balance SC Elite v5
Hoka Rocket X 3
.png)
Tracksmith Eliot Racer
.png)
For a weekly dose of MILEAGE, shoe reviews, and inspiration, sign up for Mileage Mantra, the Supwell weekly newsletter.
Find your next running shoe
Answer a few questions to find the best shoe based on your preferences and goals
